There is a moment that happens to almost every first-time Five Guys customer.
You finish your Bacon Cheeseburger, you are already satisfied, and then someone at the next table gets a shake delivered to their tray. Thick. Creamy. Coming out of a clear cup topped with whipped cream. You immediately regret not ordering one.
That is the Five Guys milkshake experience in one image.
The Five Guys milkshake menu is one of the most customizable dessert programs in fast food. Every shake starts with the same handspun vanilla base. Then you choose your mix-ins. Up to 13 of them. All completely free. The combinations you can build are genuinely staggering, and the quality of the base makes every single one of them work. And if you want something savory before your dessert, you can explore the Five Guys Sandwich Menu for options like the BLT, Veggie Sandwich, and Grilled Cheese.
This guide covers everything you need to know about the Five Guys milkshake menu in 2026: every flavor, every mix-in, prices, calories, allergens, best combinations, and honest comparisons. Let us get into it.
Five Guys MilkShake Menu with Prices, Calories and Nutrition
Bacon Shake
A creamy milkshake blended with crispy bacon pieces for a sweet and smoky flavor combination. Thick, smooth, and unique.
$0.99 (price)
80 (calories)
0 (carb)
260 (Sodium)
7 (Fats)
Oreo Cream Shake
A thick and creamy milkshake blended with crunchy Oreo cookie pieces for a rich chocolate cookie flavor. Smooth, sweet, and satisfying.
$0.99 (price)
320 (calories)
23 (carb)
48 (Sodium)
25 (Fats)
Peanut Butter Shake
A thick and creamy milkshake blended with smooth peanut butter for a rich, nutty flavor. Cool, indulgent, and perfectly blended.
$0.99 (price)
90 (calories)
4–16 (carb)
440 (Sodium)
30(Fats)
Chocolate Shake
A smooth and creamy milkshake made with rich chocolate flavor. Thick, sweet, and perfectly blended for chocolate lovers.
$0.99 (price)
40 (calories)
32 (carb)
39 (Sodium)
4 (Fats)
REESES Cups Shake
A rich and creamy milkshake blended with REESE’S Peanut Butter Cups for a perfect mix of chocolate and peanut butter flavor.
$0.99 (price)
150 (calories)
16 (carb)
98 (Sodium)
8 (Fats)
Strawberries Shake
A creamy milkshake blended with real strawberries for a fresh and fruity flavor. Smooth, sweet, and refreshing.
$0.99 (price)
20 (calories)
0 (carb)
20 (Sodium)
0 (Fats)
Caramel Shake
A thick and creamy milkshake blended with rich caramel for a smooth and sweet flavor. Perfect for those who love a classic caramel taste.
$0.99 (price)
45 (calories)
41 (carb)
98 (Sodium)
1 (Fats)
Bananas Shake
A creamy milkshake blended with real bananas for a naturally sweet and smooth flavor. Fresh, rich, and perfectly blended.
$0.99 (price)
30 (calories)
28 (carb)
10 (Sodium)
0 (Fats)
The Five Guys milkshake menu is structured differently from most fast food shake menus. There is no long list of separate flavors to choose from. Instead, every shake starts from the same handspun vanilla base, and you build your flavor from a list of free mix-ins.
The price you pay is for the base shake. The customization is entirely free.
Note: Prices below reflect 2026 US national averages and vary by location. Always confirm current pricing at your local Five Guys or at fiveguys.com.
Nutrition Info
What Makes Five Guys Milkshakes Different
Here is something the menu board does not explain clearly enough.
Five Guys milkshakes are not made from a machine that dispenses pre-mixed soft serve. Every shake is handspun to order using real vanilla ice cream and whole milk. The process takes longer than a standard fast food machine shake, and the result tastes completely different.
The vanilla base serves as the perfect foundation for creating a wide variety of flavors. Every milkshake is hand-spun to maintain consistent flavor and premium quality, and customers can customize their shakes by adding one, two, or up to 13 mix-ins at no extra cost.
That combination of real ingredients, manual preparation, and unlimited customization creates a product that sits in a genuinely different category from what most fast food chains serve.
Coffee is now a permanent member of the milkshake mix-in menu, made with a premium syrup for a rich, bold coffee flavor a recent addition that became permanent due to overwhelming customer demand.
All Five Guys Milkshake Mix-Ins List
This is where the Five Guys milkshake menu becomes genuinely extraordinary. Every mix-in is free. You can add as many as 13 of them to a single shake.
Mix-In | Flavor Profile |
Chocolate | Rich, deep cocoa |
Strawberry | Bright, fruity, natural |
Banana | Sweet, smooth, natural |
Peanut Butter | Creamy, nutty, savory |
Oreo Cookies | Chocolatey, crunchy |
Double Stuf Oreo Creme | Sweet, rich, creamy |
Bacon | Smoky, salty, crispy |
Salted Caramel | Sweet with savory finish |
REESE’S | Chocolate and peanut butter |
Coffee | Bold, rich, slightly bitter |
Whipped Cream | Light, sweet topping |
Candy Cane (Seasonal) | Cool, minty, sweet |
Some mix-ins were made for each other. Five Guys suggests several signature pairings on their official menu page. A few worth trying:
- Peanut Butter + Banana — the classic combination, clean and rich
- Chocolate + Oreo — maximum chocolate with added crunch
- Bacon + Salted Caramel — sweet, salty, and smoky in one build
- Coffee + Chocolate — a mocha-style shake built from scratch
- REESE’S + Banana — unexpected but genuinely works
Five Guys Milkshake Allergens Information
Key allergen facts for the Five Guys milkshake menu:
- Dairy: All shakes contain milk and ice cream. Five Guys has not yet introduced dairy-free alternatives for their milkshakes. If you have a dairy allergy, avoid all milkshake items.
- Gluten: Oreo and Double Stuf Oreo mix-ins contain gluten. The vanilla base itself does not, but cross-contamination risk exists in the blending process.
- Peanuts: The peanut butter mix-in contains peanuts. The REESE’S mix-in also contains peanuts. Additionally, peanut oil is used throughout the restaurant for frying and peanuts are available as a free snack in the dining area.
- Eggs: Present in some mix-ins and the ice cream base.
- Tree Nuts: Not present in the standard shake ingredients.
- Soy: Present in some mix-in ingredients.
Please inform staff about your food allergy before placing an order. Full allergen charts are available on the Five Guys official website and in-store on request.
Five Guys Milkshakes vs Competitor Shakes
How does the Five Guys milkshake menu compare against the competition?
Chain | Avg. Shake Price | Made From | Customization |
Five Guys | $5.29–$6.69 | Real ice cream, handspun | Up to 13 free mix-ins |
Shake Shack | $6.99–$8.99 | Real ice cream, handspun | Limited mix-ins |
Chick-fil-A | $4.25–$5.75 | Real ice cream | Limited flavors |
McDonald’s | $3.29–$4.49 | Soft serve blend | No customization |
Dairy Queen | $4.49–$5.99 | Soft serve | Limited mix-ins |
Wendy’s Frosty | $1.99–$3.29 | Proprietary blend | No customization |
Five Guys sits below Shake Shack on price while offering considerably more customization options. The gap in quality over McDonald’s, Wendy’s, and Dairy Queen is meaningful. The real ice cream base and handspun preparation create a fundamentally different product.
The honest comparison is Five Guys versus Shake Shack. Both use real ice cream. Both handcraft their shakes. Five Guys wins on customization depth. Shake Shack wins on certain specialty flavors and seasonal variety. Both are worth trying.
Best Five Guys Milkshake Combinations to Try in 2026
After extensive menu testing, here are the combinations that consistently stand out:
For chocolate lovers: Double Chocolate with Oreo Cookies. The fudge base plus the cookie crunch creates maximum chocolate satisfaction without being one-dimensional.
For the sweet and salty crowd: Bacon with Salted Caramel. This is the most adventurous combination on the Five Guys milkshake menu and the one most likely to convert skeptics.
For coffee enthusiasts: Coffee with Chocolate. Essentially a mocha milkshake built from scratch. Rich, bold, and satisfying alongside a burger meal.
For peanut butter fans: Peanut Butter with Banana. The classic combination that works in every format it appears in. Clean, rich, and not too sweet.
For first-time visitors: Strawberry with Whipped Cream only. The quality of the real strawberry mix-in speaks for itself without any distractions.
How to Order Five Guys Milkshakes Online
- You can order milkshakes through the Five Guys website at fiveguys.com or through their mobile app.
- The online ordering interface allows full customization:
- select your base shake, choose your mix-ins from the full list, and add whipped cream if desired.
- Payment options include Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal, and standard credit or debit cards.
- Delivery is available through DoorDash, Grubhub, and Uber Eats depending on your location, though shake quality can decline slightly with longer delivery times due to melting.
For the best shake experience, in-store or quick curbside pickup is the recommended approach.
Tips for Ordering from the Five Guys Milkshake Menu
A few practical tips that experienced Five Guys customers swear by:
Do not add more than four mix-ins on your first order. The temptation with 13 free mix-ins is to use all 13. Resist it. More mix-ins does not always mean better flavor. Pick three or four that complement each other and let the vanilla base do the rest.
Pair your shake with your food choice deliberately. A rich Peanut Butter shake alongside a Bacon Cheeseburger can be overwhelming. The Strawberry or Coffee shake clears the palate better between bites.
Try the Bacon shake before you judge it. It is the most frequently overlooked item on the Five Guys milkshake menu and the one that generates the most positive surprise among first-time orderers.
Ask about seasonal availability. The Candy Cane Crunch and other seasonal offerings are not always available. Ask before you plan around them.
Order ahead for pickup. Shakes take a few minutes to prepare properly because they are handspun to order. Online ordering reduces wait time.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many mix-ins can I add to a Five Guys milkshake?
You can add up to 13 mix-ins to any shake, all completely free of charge.
What is the most popular milkshake at Five Guys?
The Peanut Butter Shake and the Oreo Cookie Shake are consistently among the top-ordered items. The Coffee Shake, newly permanent in 2026, is rapidly gaining popularity.
Is the Five Guys bacon milkshake actually good?
Yes, genuinely. The combination of sweet vanilla ice cream and salty, crispy applewood-smoked bacon creates a sweet-and-salty profile that surprises most skeptics positively.
Can I customize my Five Guys milkshake online?
Yes. The Five Guys website and app support full milkshake customization including mix-in selection when placing orders.
Are Five Guys milkshakes handmade?
Yes. Every shake is handspun to order using real vanilla ice cream and whole milk. They are not made from a machine-dispensed soft serve mix.
Does Five Guys offer a coffee milkshake?
Yes. The Coffee mix-in became a permanent menu item due to popular demand. It is available at all locations year-round as of 2025 and 2026.
Final Words
The Five Guys milkshake menu does not ask you to choose from a pre-built list and accept whatever comes out. It asks you to build something. That approach reflects the same philosophy that runs through every other part of the Five Guys operation: real ingredients, real customization, and no shortcuts.
The combination of pure ingredients, manual preparation, and extensive customization makes Five Guys milkshakes genuinely unmatched in the fast food space. And if you want something savory before dessert, many customers pair their shake with items from the Five Guys Hot Dogs Menu or the Five Guys Fries Menu, both of which offer the same quality ingredients and generous portions the brand is known for.
At $5.29 to $6.69, they are priced at the premium end of fast food desserts. The quality justifies that gap consistently. A handspun shake made with real ice cream and real fruit simply tastes different from a machine-dispensed soft serve blend, and the difference is immediately obvious.
If you are building your perfect Five Guys meal in 2026, do not skip the milkshake. Order the Coffee shake with a hint of Chocolate. Or the Peanut Butter with Banana. Or, just once, the Bacon shake.
You will understand why Five Guys customers keep coming back for theirs.
What is your go-to milkshake combination from the Five Guys milkshake menu? Drop it in the comments. The best custom builds come from people who have genuinely experimented with the menu.